Each year, on average, animals are killed in around 17 major barn fires. In the period 2012 through to November 2020, this led to the death of almost 1.3 million animals. The number of animals killed in barn fires is growing year on year. The Safety Board believes that this trend, that goes hand in hand with considerable animal suffering, must be reversed.
The Safety Board has seen a continuous growth in animal housing, a situation that further increases the likelihood of very large numbers of animals being killed in the event of a barn fire. Jeroen Dijsselbloem, Chairman of the Dutch Safety Board, commented, “Both within the sector and within government, there is insufficient attention for animal safety in the event of fire breaking out in the ever larger barns. This is one area in which the Dutch livestock industry must improve.”
Limited effect of initiatives
In 2011, the number of barn fires led the sector, the Dutch Society for the Protection of Animals (Dierenbescherming) and insurers to draw up action plans aimed at reducing the number of barn fires, and animal suffering. These action plans have not brought about the intended effects. The average number of animals that die in barn fires each year has in fact increased. In addition to these voluntary initiatives within the sector, the government laid down a number of statutory fire safety requirements in the Building Decree, in 2014. However, these building regulations apply only to new barns and renovated barns. There are almost no laws or regulations aimed at improving the fire safety of existing barns.
Risks of economies of scale
The Safety Board sees a real need to take a different look at livestock farming in the Netherlands. The fire safety risks are partly the result of the way in which animals are accommodated in factory farming: in large numbers in enclosed housing, without escape routes. To make matters worse, larger livestock farms are increasingly equipped with technical installations that in turn generate additional fire safety risks. This fact demands greater expertise among livestock farmers, in the field of safety management, similar to the requirements that apply for example in industry. It is up to government to impose requirements on the expertise of farmers that tie in with the size of the farm enterprise, and the risks present. The situation is made all the more urgent since due to growing economies of scale, livestock farmers are responsible for ever larger numbers of animals.
Make fire safety for animals compulsory
Reducing the number of barn fires calls for a new, more result-oriented approach. The Dutch Safety Board recommends that the Minister of Agriculture, Nature and Food Quality takes the lead in this development. This can for example be achieved by setting a target for livestock farmers to reduce the number of barn fires, and to make the taking of measures to improve fire safety for animals a legal requirement.